A 45-pound muskie caught on Greenwood Lake has sparked a debate over state records and fishing regulations. Victor Gelman, an ice fisherman from Warwick, New York, reeled in the massive fish on February 24th, 2026. The catch, weighing 45.02 pounds, is a potential New Jersey state record, but the lake's location on the New York-New Jersey border complicates matters.
Gelman, an experienced angler, was fishing alone on the frozen lake when he hooked the fish of a lifetime. Despite harsh conditions, he managed to land the muskie after an eight-hour battle. The fish measured an impressive 51.125 inches long with a 27-inch girth, surpassing New Jersey's current muskellunge record by a significant margin.
The interesting twist lies in the lake's status as a 'boundary water,' meaning it spans both states. While Gelman caught the fish on the New York side, the catch is still recognized as the largest muskie ever recorded from Greenwood Lake and in New Jersey waters. This has led to a debate about which state should claim the record.
Gelman, who owns a chocolate company, initially considered releasing the fish but decided to donate it to the Hackettstown State Fish Hatchery. He wanted to ensure the fish would be studied and its impressive size could be attributed to the efforts of state biologists who have worked on stocking and researching the lake's fishery.
This incident highlights the complexities of fishing regulations and the passion of anglers. It also showcases the importance of responsible fishing practices and the role of biologists in maintaining healthy fish populations. As the debate continues, it serves as a reminder of the challenges and rewards of pursuing record-breaking catches in shared waters.
